Florida case law has repeatedly upheld the right of persons
who meet the criteria in Jenks vs. State of Florida (1st DCA
1991) to present medical necessity as a defense for the possession,
consumption and cultivation of the herb known as cannabis. Although
medical cannabis use is widely accepted in certain sciences,
public opinion about its potential for harm varies greatly.
While some still hold to the theory that marijuana use is a
“gateway” drug, the 1999 Institute of Medicine report,
“Marijuana and Medicine: Assessing the Science Base”
concluded that assumption to be false. As presented at The First
National Clinical Conference on Cannabis Therapeutics, held
April 2000 at the University of Iowa, by Dr. Janet Joy the Study
Director, the results of this 18 month long study which took
testimony from over one hundred experts, was that Cannabis use
did not lead to other drug use, that it was an extremely safe
and effective medicine and that it was not addictive.
Jenks not only established case law in Florida it also recognized
cannabis’ therapeutic value in treating AIDS related symptoms.
In 2000 at the International Conference on AIDS, the consortium
recommended marijuana as treatment for AIDS related symptoms.
Currently 80,000 people are infected with AIDS in Florida.
Internationally known neurologists are studying the therapeutic
effects of Cannabis on MS, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s
Disease and Lou Gehrig’s Disease. Dr Sanchez-Ramos, the
Director of Movement Disorders at the University of South Florida,
has been studying the neuromuscular effects of Cannabis. County
based support groups average 25 members per group, these suffers
of Multiple Sclerosis and Lou Gehrig’s Disease are terminally
ill and many have already discovered the medical benefits of
cannabis on their disorder.
Studies from around the globe are identifying a variety of
benefits derived from cannabis use. Medical uses for Cannabis
were published yearly in the Pharmacoepia of the United States
from its inception through 1941, when Cannabis was removed as
a by-product of the Marijuana Tax Act of 1937. Evidence of the
medical benefits of Cannabis are widely accepted and polls conducted
by the Miami Herald clearly show Floridians who vote will support
therapeutic access to Cannabis for ill patients under the care
of their physician.
Patients in Florida are using marijuana medically. A conservative
estimation identifies potentially tens of thousands could use
marijuana and qualify under the current medical necessity defense.
These ill persons are forced to seek access to their medicine
from black market sources. Patients who use marijuana medically
are also subject to arrest in order to prove their need. The
Supreme Court decision of May 2001 noted that had the Oakland
Cannabis Club been operating as an agent of the Government distributing
for a research program they would not have been in violation
of Federal Law. States that have passed medical marijuana into
law have met the challenge of distribution in several ways.
Attached is a overview provided by the Marijuana Policy Project
outlining distribution methods and state laws.
The conflict between the care of our sick persons and the law
in Florida is creating a vacuum in which Doctors can’t
treat their patients and patients can’t trust their doctor.
The cost to society from the fear of drug abuse and addiction
must not include sacrificing ill persons who have found relief
through Cannabis.
The Solution
The Coalition Advocating Medical Marijuana proposes to work
with the Office of Drug Control and the Department of Health
and Human Services to identify persons who qualify for the medical
necessity defense outlined in Jenks and provide them access
to medical grade Cannabis under the care of health care professionals.
Under the proposed program five critical points are addressed:
• Creation of a medical quality source of Cannabis
• Identification and qualifications of persons participating
as patients and caregivers
• Dosage and distribution process of the Cannabis to qualified
persons
• Creation of a study protocol to measure therapeutic
results
• Education of the public and health care professionals
about the value of therapeutic Cannabis
Creation of a quality supply of marijuana
Rick Doblin, Ph.D., a native of Florida, has created a protocol
for licensing and growing marijuana that will meet the approval
process of the Food and Drug Administration. This protocol could
easily be implemented at the University of Gainesville Agricultural
College for the pilot stage of this program. Horticulturists
would be able to regulate the growing, harvesting and preparation
process to ensure that each plant met predetermined therapeutic
standards.
Seeds of marijuana are an international commodity and easily
available in some countries. The science of cross breeding has
created seeds that produce a consistent product. Studies of
marijuana strains on certain illnesses will be adapted and effective
strains reproduced for clinical tests.
At the University of Mississippi the Federal Government has
been growing marijuana for research since the 1970’s.
This is currently the only federally approved grow site in the
country, with a number of states operating “test sites”
for growing medical grade Cannabis as well as hemp.
Several states are looking at funding orphan drug programs
to research the medical effects of marijuana. These states will
be seeking additional Cannabis product and the University Agricultural
Programs are ideal candidates to benefit from those studies
if they are among the first to organize and operate Cannabis
research acreage.
Identification and Qualifications of
persons participating as patients and caregivers
The Florida Supreme Court has shouldered the burden of qualifications
for the pilot program. Patients who meet three criteria can
already qualify for exemption from for the medical necessity
defense. 1. The patient did not intentionally bring about the
circumstances that caused him to break the law. 2. The defendant
could not accomplish the same objective by alternative lawful
means. 3. The unlawful act was less serious an offense to legal
decency that the wrong the defendant sought to avoid. While
new studies being conducted are showing the benefits of marijuana
for a variety of ailments, case law does not support an open-ended
research program at this time. An oversight committee may be
formed to review case files of persons applying for the “Florida
Compassionate Medicine Study Program”.
Since consultation with a physician is a major factor in Jenks,
we will look to the medical community and the Department of
Health and Human Services to provide initial qualifications.
Dr. Mark Laporter introduced a resolution to the Florida Medical
Association in 1997 that was passed by the membership. This
resolution stated “ BE IT RESOLVED: That the FMA urges
the state and federal government and the US Public Health Service
to open limited access to medical marijuana by reopening the
investigational new drug program to new applicants. BE IT FURTHER
RESOLVED: That the FMA shall urge Congress, the FDA, NIDA, DEA
and all other relevant governmental agencies to expedite unimpeded
research into the therapeutic potential of smokable marijuana….”
Dosage and distribution of Cannabis
to qualified persons
The correct dosage for any individual patient shall be decided
by that patient and personal physician. This is the standard
method by which all medication dosages are decided and should
not be varied for Cannabis. Distribution to the federally supplied
patients in the United States is done through a pharmacy and
it is envisioned this procedure could be replicated for a pilot
program and beyond.
Added protocols for distribution to other research programs
would allow for increased study of this controversial plant.
Florida’s Compassionate Medical Study Program will lead
the way for other states that are struggling with distribution
to adapt this model. While a smokeless form of Cannabis may
be the end result of such studies, many patients with fatal
long-term diseases who have found relief in this natural form
should not be denied access to medical grade Cannabis, nor should
they be forced to be the test subjects for inferior Cannabis
products.
Creation of a study protocol to measure
therapeutic results
Approved Cannabis gardens and/or contractors will operate under
the Department of Agriculture. A study protocol shall be written
by participating physicians to evalute the therapeutic results
of clinical use.
Education of the public and health care
professionals
Great strides will be taken to assure that the pilot program
is publicized widely, that public education about the therapeutic
value of Cannabis be integrated in such publicity, and is designed
to inform and locate patients with a recognized need.
An adjunct program of education shall be developed to insure
the complete and proper education of all MD’s and RN’s
in the proper dosage and administration of medical Cannabis.
|